UNIT: MEASUREMENT

ACT-Based Writing: Argumentative Essay on Measurement Accuracy

OBJECTIVE:

This activity enhances students’ persuasive writing and critical thinking skills by having them construct an argument about the importance of measurement accuracy in various fields.

MATERIALS NEEDED:

Essay prompt handouts

Rubric for evaluating argument structure and clarity

Peer review worksheets

student directions:

Goals:

In this writing activity, you will construct a persuasive essay that argues a position on the role of measurement accuracy in professional fields. You will practice how to develop a clear claim, support it with strong evidence, and address opposing viewpoints—skills that are crucial for success on the ACT Writing section and in real-world writing situations.

STUDENT DIRECTIONS

Step 1: Understand the Prompt

Read the prompt carefully:

“In industries such as engineering, healthcare, and construction, precision in measurement is critical. Write an essay arguing whether digital measurement tools should replace traditional manual tools in all professional settings.”

Your task is to:

Take a clear position (YES, they should replace all manual tools — OR — NO, they should not completely replace them).

Support your position with logical reasoning, examples, and relevant facts.

Address at least one counterargument and explain why your argument still holds.

Step 2: Plan Your Essay

Use your planning sheet or notebook to outline:

Your thesis statement (your main claim).

Three key points that support your argument.

These can include examples from engineering, construction, healthcare, or scientific experiments.

At least one counterargument and a response (refutation).

Think about what someone who disagrees with you might say—and how you can respond logically.

Step 3: Write Your Essay

Your essay should include:

Introduction

Brief background about the importance of measurement in real-world jobs.

A clear thesis statement that presents your position.

Body Paragraphs

Paragraph 1: Strongest supporting reason with explanation and example.

Paragraph 2: Second reason or example from a different field or scenario.

Paragraph 3: Counterargument and your rebuttal.

🔹 Conclusion

Restate your claim and summarize key points.

End with a final thought on why your position matters in real-world applications.

Step 4: Peer Review

Exchange essays with a partner.

Use the Peer Review Worksheet to provide feedback on:

Clarity of the thesis

Strength and relevance of evidence

Organization and flow of ideas

Proper handling of a counterargument

Grammar and sentence clarity

Be respectful and constructive in your feedback!

Step 5: Reflect and Discuss

As a class or in small groups, discuss:

What made some arguments more convincing than others?

How can sentence structure, transitions, and evidence improve clarity?

How does this connect to the ACT Writing task and real-world communication?